Call Or Text Us Anytime 910-691-3306

The Biggest Mistakes Sellers Make (and How to Avoid Them)

Selling your home is a big decision, and in a market like Northeastern NC and Coastal VA, the right strategy makes all the difference. The truth is, most sellers don’t lose money because of the market, they lose money because of avoidable mistakes. Here are the biggest missteps I see, and how you can stay way ahead of them.

Table of Contents

Overpricing From the Start

This is the #1 mistake sellers make.

It’s tempting to “try high and see what happens,” but here’s what actually happens:

  • You miss your strongest buyers during the first few days

  • Your home sits longer

  • You lose negotiating power

  • Buyers assume something is wrong

  • You may end up selling for less than you would’ve with the right price

In our area, the first 48–72 hours are everything.
Pricing it right from day one always pays off.

Skipping Simple Repairs

Loose doorknobs, peeling paint, broken blinds, loose railings, stained carpet, these seem small, but buyers notice. And in their minds, small issues = bigger unseen problems.

Most repairs cost very little compared to the peace of mind they give buyers.

Fixing the little things strengthens your position and can help prevent long inspection negotiations later.

Not Preparing the Home Before Photos

Online photos are your home’s first showing.
If they’re dark, cluttered, or unprepared, buyers simply scroll right past.

Common mistakes include:

  • Counters full of items

  • Bulky furniture blocking spaces

  • Messy rooms

  • Poor lighting

  • Dirty floors or windows

A few hours of prep can make a dramatic difference, especially in listing photos.

Letting Emotions Drive Decisions

Sellers often price based on how they feel about their home, not the data.

You might love your upgrades, you might know the memories you made there… but buyers only see what the market supports.

Emotions are normal, but they shouldn’t drive pricing or negotiations.
That’s why having an agent who can bring calm, realistic guidance is huge.

Turning Down Showings

When your home is on the market, every showing counts.

Saying “no” too often means:

  • Fewer potential buyers

  • Less competition

  • Longer time on market

  • Lower offers

It’s inconvenient, but temporary, and the faster we get people in, the faster we get your home sold.

Thinking “Clean Enough” Is Clean Enough

A quick tidy isn’t the same as a deep clean.

Buyers want a home that feels fresh. That includes:

  • Baseboards

  • Windows

  • Appliances

  • Bathroom grout

  • Flooring

  • Ceiling fans

  • Light fixtures

A sparkling clean home makes buyers feel comfortable and confident.

Ignoring Curb Appeal

In NE NC & Coastal VA, where porches, yards, and drive-up appeal matter, the outside sets the tone.

Sellers often forget that buyers decide how they feel before they even walk in.

Simple improvements work wonders:

  • Fresh mulch

  • Trimmed bushes

  • Swept porch

  • Clean exterior

  • A healthy lawn

  • Updated porch lights

Your yard is your home’s first impression, make it a good one.

Being Unprepared for the Inspection

Inspections can feel scary, but they don’t have to be.

The biggest mistakes sellers make here are:

  • Not fixing obvious issues beforehand

  • Panicking over normal findings

  • Refusing reasonable repair requests

  • Not understanding what’s “common” vs. “serious”

I’ll walk you through this stage so you know exactly what to expect, and how to respond.

Hiring the Wrong Agent

Not all agents approach selling the same way.

Some list your home… Others actually market it.

The right agent should:

  • Know your local market inside and out

  • Communicate clearly

  • Guide you through every step

  • Protect your interests

  • Price strategically

  • Negotiate fiercely

  • Give honest advice (not just what you want to hear)

Hiring the Wrong Agent

Not all agents approach selling the same way.

Some list your home… Others actually market it.

The right agent should:

  • Know your local market inside and out

  • Communicate clearly

  • Guide you through every step

  • Protect your interests

  • Price strategically

  • Negotiate fiercely

  • Give honest advice (not just what you want to hear)

Selling Doesn’t Have to Be Complicated

Most of these mistakes are easy to avoid, especially when you have someone walking beside you who knows the local market and understands what buyers want in Northeastern NC and Coastal VA.

If you’re thinking about selling, I’d love to guide you through the process and help you get the best possible result.

Whenever you’re ready, just reach out.

If you’re thinking about making a move and have any questions call or text me anytime:

910-691-3306

Subscribe to Our Weekly Events Newsletter

Christie Peyton - Your East Coast NC & VA Realtor

CHRISTIE PEYTON

Hey friends, I’m Christie Peyton! I’m here to share weekly inspiration about the best local events, restaurants, cozy coffee spots, weekend adventures, and fun things to do around our little corner of the East Coast.

I love highlighting the places, people, and moments that make life here feel special, from sunny days by the water to simple small-town favorites and everything in between.

I’m so glad you’re here. Let’s enjoy coastal life together. 💙